I'm currently writing code to use Amazon's S3 REST API and I notice different behavior where the only difference seems to be the Amazon endpoint URI that I use, e.g., https://s3.amazonaws.com vs. https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com.
Examples of different behavior for the the GET Bucket (List Objects) call:
Using one endpoint, it includes the "folder" in the results, e.g.:
/path/subfolder/
/path/subfolder/file1.txt
/path/subfolder/file2.txt
and, using the other endpoint, it does not include the "folder" in the results:
/path/subfolder/file1.txt
/path/subfolder/file2.txt
Using one endpoint, it represents "folders" using a trailing / as shown above and, using the other endpoint, it uses a trailing _$folder$:
/path/subfolder_$folder$
/path/subfolder/file1.txt
/path/subfolder/file2.txt
Why the differences? How can I make it return results in a consistent manner regardless of endpoint?
Note that I get these same odd results even if I use Amazon's own command-line AWS S3 client, so it's not my code.
And the contents of the buckets should be irrelevant anyway.
Your assertion notwithstanding, your issue is exactly about the content of the buckets, and not something S3 is doing -- the S3 API has no concept of folders. None. The S3 console can display folders, but this is for convenience -- the folders are not really there -- or if there are folder-like entities, they're irrelevant and not needed.
In Amazon S3, buckets and objects are the primary resources, where objects are stored in buckets. Amazon S3 has a flat structure with no hierarchy like you would see in a typical file system. However, for the sake of organizational simplicity, the Amazon S3 console supports the folder concept as a means of grouping objects. Amazon S3 does this by using key name prefixes for objects.
http://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/UG/FolderOperations.html
So why are you seeing this?
Either you've been using EMR/Hadoop, or some other code written by someone who took a bad example and ran with it... or is doing something differently than it should have been done for quite some time.
Amazon EMR is a web service that uses a managed Hadoop framework to process, distribute, and interact with data in AWS data stores, including Amazon S3. Because S3 uses a key-value pair storage system, the Hadoop file system implements directory support in S3 by creating empty files with the
<directoryname>_$folder$suffix.https://aws.amazon.com/premiumsupport/knowledge-center/emr-s3-empty-files/
This may have been something the S3 console did many years ago, and apparently (since you don't report seeing them in the console) it still supports displaying such objects as folders in the console... but the S3 console no longer creates them this way, if it ever did.
I've mirrored the bucket "folder" layout exactly
If you create a folder in the console, an empty object with the key "foldername/" is created. This in turn is used to display a folder that you can navigate into, and upload objects with keys beginning with that folder name as a prefix.
The Amazon S3 console treats all objects that have a forward slash "/" character as the last (trailing) character in the key name as a folder
http://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/UG/FolderOperations.html
If you just create objects using the API, then "my/object.txt" appears in the console as "object.txt" inside folder "my" even though there is no "my/" object created... so if the objects are created with the API, you'd see neither style of "folder" in the object listing.
That is probably a bug in the API endpoint which includes the "folder" - S3 internally doesn't actually have a folder structure, but instead is just a set of keys associated with files, where keys (for convenience) can contain slash-separated paths which then show up as "folders" in the web interface. There is the option in the API to specify a prefix, which I believe can be any part of the key up to and including part of the filename.
EMR's s3 client is not the apache one, so I can't speak accurately about it.
In ASF hadoop releases (and HDP, CDH)
$folder$ as its folder delimiter.The S3A clients strip out all folder markers when you list things; S3A uses them to simulate empty dirs and deletes all parent markers when you create child file/dir entries.
Whatever you have which processes GET should just ignore entries with "/" or $folder at the end.
As to why they are different, the local EMRFS is a different codepath, using dynamo for implementing consistency. At a guess, it doesn't need to mock empty dirs, as the DDB tables will host all directory entries.