Business
Jobs
  • About Us
  • Solutions
    • Job Postings
      Post your job and receive qualified candidates in 48h.
    • Candidate Assessments
      500+ technical and psychological tests, plus anti-fraud.
    • Headhunting
      Tailor-made executive search from start to finish.
    • Payroll + EOR
      Payroll dispersal and EOR across 15+ LATAM countries.
  • Pricing
  • Jobs

0

1.3K
Views
Is a function that calls Math.random() pure?

Is the following a pure function?

function test(min,max) {
   return  Math.random() * (max - min) + min;
}

My understanding is that a pure function follows these conditions:

  1. It returns a value computed from the parameters
  2. It doesn't do any work other than calculating the return value

If this definition is correct, is my function a pure function? Or is my understanding of what defines a pure function incorrect?

over 4 years ago · Santiago Trujillo
3 answers
Answer question

0

No, it's not. Given the same input, this function will return different values. And then you can't build a 'table' that maps the input and the outputs.

From the Wikipedia article for Pure function:

The function always evaluates the same result value given the same argument value(s). The function result value cannot depend on any hidden information or state that may change while program execution proceeds or between different executions of the program, nor can it depend on any external input from I/O devices

Also, another thing is that a pure function can be replaced with a table which represents the mapping from the input and output, as explained in this thread.

If you want to rewrite this function and change it to a pure function, you should pass the random value as an argument too

function test(random, min, max) {
   return random * (max - min) + min;
}

and then call it this way (example, with 2 and 5 as min and max):

test( Math.random(), 2, 5)
over 4 years ago · Santiago Trujillo Report

0

The simple answer to your question is that Math.random() violates rule #2.

Many other answers here have pointed out that the presence of Math.random() means that this function is not pure. But I think it's worth saying why Math.random() taints functions that use it.

Like all pseudorandom number generators, Math.random() starts with a "seed" value. It then uses that value as the starting point for a chain of low-level bit manipulations or other operations that result in an unpredictable (but not really random) output.

In JavaScript, the process involved is implementation-dependent, and unlike many other languages, JavaScript provides no way to select the seed:

The implementation selects the initial seed to the random number generation algorithm; it cannot be chosen or reset by the user.

That's why this function isn't pure: JavaScript is essentially using an implicit function parameter that you have no control over. It's reading that parameter from data calculated and stored elsewhere, and therefore violates rule #2 in your definition.

If you wanted to make this a pure function, you could use one of the alternative random number generators described here. Call that generator seedable_random. It takes one parameter (the seed) and returns a "random" number. Of course, this number isn't really random at all; it is uniquely determined by the seed. That's why this is a pure function. The output of seedable_random is only "random" in the sense that predicting the output based on the input is difficult.

The pure version of this function would need to take three parameters:

function test(min, max, seed) {
   return  seedable_random(seed) * (max - min) + min;
}

For any given triple of (min, max, seed) parameters, this will always return the same result.

Note that if you wanted the output of seedable_random to be truly random, you'd need to find a way to randomize the seed! And whatever strategy you used would inevitably be non-pure, because it would require you to gather information from a source outside your function. As mtraceur and jpmc26 remind me, this includes all physical approaches: hardware random number generators, webcams with lens caps, atmospheric noise collectors -- even lava lamps. All of these involve using data calculated and stored outside the function.

over 4 years ago · Santiago Trujillo Report

0

A pure function is a function where the return value is only determined by its input values, without observable side effects

By using Math.random, you are determining its value by something other than input values. It's not a pure function.

source

over 4 years ago · Santiago Trujillo Report
Answer question
Find remote jobs

Discover the new way to find a job!

Top jobs
Top job categories
Business
Post vacancy Pricing Sales
Legal
Terms and conditions Privacy policy
© 2026 PeakU Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Andres GPT
Show me some job opportunities
There's an error!