There is question about using exit in C++. The answer discusses that it is not good idea mainly because of RAII, e.g., if exit is called somewhere in code, destructors of objects will not be called, hence, if for example a destructor was meant to write data to file, this will not happen, because the destructor was not called.
I was interested how is this situation in C. Are similar issues applicable also in C? I thought since in C we don't use constructors/destructors, situation might be different in C. So is it ok to use exit in C? For example I have seen following functions sometimes used in C:
void die(const char *message)
{
if(errno) {
perror(message);
} else {
printf("ERROR: %s\n", message);
}
exit(1);
}
Rather than abort(), the exit() function in C is considered to be a "graceful" exit.
From C11 (N1570) 7.22.4.4/p2 The exit function (emphasis mine):
The
exitfunction causes normal program termination to occur.
The Standard also says in 7.22.4.4/p4 that:
Next, all open streams with unwritten buffered data are flushed, all open streams are closed, and all files created by the
tmpfilefunction are removed.
It is also worth looking at 7.21.3/p5 Files:
If the
mainfunction returns to its original caller, or if theexitfunction is called, all open files are closed (hence all output streams are flushed) before program termination. Other paths to program termination, such as calling theabortfunction, need not close all files properly.
However, as mentioned in comments below you can't assume that it will cover every other resource, so you may need to resort to atexit() and define callbacks for their release individually. In fact it is exactly what atexit() is intended to do, as it says in 7.22.4.2/p2 The atexit function:
The
atexitfunction registers the function pointed to byfunc, to be called without arguments at normal program termination.
Notably, the C standard does not say precisely what should happen to objects of allocated storage duration (i.e. malloc()), thus requiring you be aware of how it is done on particular implementation. For modern, host-oriented OS it is likely that the system will take care of it, but still you might want to handle this by yourself in order to silence memory debuggers such as Valgrind.
Yes, it is ok to use exit in C.
To ensure all buffers and graceful orderly shutdown, it would be recommended to use this function atexit, more information on this here
An example code would be like this:
void cleanup(void){
/* example of closing file pointer and free up memory */
if (fp) fclose(fp);
if (ptr) free(ptr);
}
int main(int argc, char **argv){
/* ... */
atexit(cleanup);
/* ... */
return 0;
}
Now, whenever exit is called, the function cleanup will get executed, which can house graceful shutdown, clean up of buffers, memory etc.
You don't have constructors and destructors but you could have resources (e.g. files, streams, sockets) and it is important to close them correctly. A buffer could not be written synchronously, so exiting from the program without correctly closing the resource first, could lead to corruption.